Add Consumer Echo as a preferred source on Google

How we make money. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more ›

Best Soup Makers: I Tested 3 to See Which One Is Worth Buying

Split photo: the Homtone soup maker with its brown user manual on the left, the red-handled Potlimepan soup maker with its white user manual on the right
If you buy through our links we may earn a commission. It never changes what we recommend.Learn more ›

Making homemade soup sounds simple enough, but between chopping ingredients, cooking everything, blending it and cleaning up afterward, it can turn into more of a project than you’d planned. That’s where soup makers come in. These appliances promise to take some of the work out of making soup by combining cooking and blending in one machine.

Tested

I tested three different options: the Homtone 1.6L Soup Maker, the Potlimepan 1.6L Soup Maker and the Milkmond 8-in-1 Milk Maker. The Homtone and Potlimepan are dedicated soup makers, while the Milkmond is mainly designed for plant-based milk but also has a soup function.

All three produced smooth results, but they differed in capacity, noise, cleaning and overall versatility. Based on my testing, the Milkmond stood out for versatility, while the two dedicated soup makers were better for larger batches. Here’s what I found.

Quick comparison: the best soup makers

Scores and notes reflect my own hands-on testing; capacity and programs come from each listing.
Soup maker Score Best for Capacity
Homtone 1.6L Soup Maker 8/10 Larger batches 1.6 liters
Potlimepan 1.6L Soup Maker 8/10 Simple controls 1.6 liters
Milkmond 8-in-1 Milk Maker 9/10 Versatility 1 liter

The three soup makers I tested

  • Homtone 1.6L Soup Maker: A dedicated soup maker with a 1.6-liter capacity, smooth and chunky soup settings, more preset programs and a cleaning mode.
  • Potlimepan 1.6L Soup Maker: Another dedicated soup maker with a 1.6-liter capacity, a digital display and multiple preset programs for soup, smoothies and more.
  • Milkmond 8-in-1 Milk Maker: A smaller, multipurpose appliance that makes plant-based milk, soup, smoothies and other drinks. It has a 1-liter capacity.

How I tested the soup makers

I wanted to see how well each machine handled blending, how easy the controls were to use, how noisy they were and how much effort cleaning took.

I used the soup function on all three machines. For the Homtone and Potlimepan, I blended cooked tomatoes and garlic, while I used cooked onions in the Milkmond. All of the ingredients ultimately went into the same soup.

I selected the smooth soup setting on the two dedicated soup makers. I didn’t test the chunky soup settings or the smoothie programs, so I’ll stick to what I actually experienced when discussing performance.

One thing worth mentioning: I used ingredients that were already cooked, so this mainly tested how well the machines blend rather than how well they cook raw ingredients from scratch.

Homtone 1.6L Soup Maker: Best for larger batches

Homtone stainless steel soup maker with a black lid and handle on a kitchen counter, in front of its boxCheck price at Amazon
Image: Holly Phillips

The Homtone 1.6L Soup Maker was one of the two dedicated soup makers I tested, with a 1.6-liter capacity. It has separate smooth and chunky soup settings, along with additional programs for other blending tasks.

What I liked

The Homtone handled the tomatoes and garlic well, producing the smooth consistency I wanted for my soup. The controls were easy to understand, and I didn’t have much trouble figuring out which setting to use.

I also appreciated the cleaning mode. It’s not immediately obvious from looking at the button panel, though, so I had to check the instruction manual to figure out how to use it. Once I found it, it was a nice feature to have.

Hand lifting the black Homtone soup maker lid to show the blade attached underneath, above the stainless steel jug
Image: Holly Phillips

What could be better

The biggest downside was the noise. When the machine first started blending the tomatoes, it was relatively quiet. As the ingredients broke down and the blending continued, however, the machine became noticeably louder. It’s not necessarily a dealbreaker, but it’s worth keeping in mind if you’re sensitive to appliance noise.

Product details

  • Capacity: 1.6 liters (about 1.7 quarts), up to four servings per batch
  • Programs: smooth soup, chunky soup and more preset settings, plus a cleaning mode
  • Timing: smooth soup in about 21 minutes, chunky in about 28, per the listing
  • Jug: BPA-free stainless steel
  • Color: black and stainless steel
Best for larger batches

A practical option if you want a dedicated soup maker with enough capacity for a larger batch. It blended my ingredients smoothly, the cleaning mode is a useful bonus and the controls were easy to use. It offers less versatility than the Milkmond.

Pros

  • 1.6-liter capacity
  • Smooth blending results
  • Dedicated cleaning mode

Cons

  • Gets louder as blending goes on
  • Cleaning mode isn’t obvious on the control panel

Potlimepan 1.6L Soup Maker: Best for simple controls

Hand holding the red handle of the Potlimepan stainless steel soup maker, its recipe booklet on the counterCheck price at Amazon
Image: Holly Phillips

The Potlimepan 1.6L Soup Maker has the same 1.6-liter capacity as the Homtone, making it another dedicated soup maker and a good option if you’re hoping to prepare more than a single serving at a time.

It features a digital display and six preset programs, including smooth soup, chunky soup and blending options.

What I liked

I found the controls intuitive and easy to navigate. The machine also blended the cooked tomatoes and garlic well, and the finished consistency was just as smooth as the other two machines.

The digital display makes it easy to see which program you’ve selected, and the multiple settings give flexibility beyond soup-making.

Potlimepan soup maker head lifted out of the stainless steel jug, showing the blade and the control panel with digital display
Image: Holly Phillips

What could be better

Like the Homtone, the Potlimepan became louder as it continued blending. It also doesn’t appear to have a dedicated self-cleaning program, which is worth noting if that’s an important feature to you.

That said, I didn’t have any particular trouble cleaning it after use.

Product details

  • Capacity: 1.6 liters, three to five portions per batch, per the listing
  • Programs: six presets for hot and cold recipes, including smooth soup, chunky soup and smoothies
  • Timing: smooth soup in about 25 minutes, chunky in about 29, per the listing
  • Power: 900 watts
  • Display: digital
  • Color: red, black and stainless steel
Best for simple controls

A solid option if you want a larger soup maker with multiple preset programs and easy-to-understand controls. It blended my ingredients smoothly, and the digital display makes it easy to see which program you’ve selected. It is less versatile than the Milkmond.

Pros

  • 1.6-liter capacity
  • Intuitive controls and digital display
  • Smooth blending results

Cons

  • Gets louder as blending goes on
  • No advertised self-cleaning program

Milkmond 8-in-1 Milk Maker: Most versatile

White Milkmond 8-in-1 milk maker with a glass lid on a kitchen counter, its box behind itCheck price at Amazon
Image: Holly Phillips

The Milkmond 8-in-1 Milk Maker is different from the other two appliances. Rather than being designed only for soup, it’s mainly a plant-based milk maker that also makes soup, smoothies and other blends.

It has a smaller 1-liter capacity, but it comes with some useful extras.

What I liked

The Milkmond produced a smooth result when I blended the cooked onions. It was also somewhat quieter than the two dedicated soup makers. The blending happens in intervals rather than continuously, which may help explain the difference I noticed.

I also liked its small design. It’s smaller than the other two machines, which could make it a better fit for a kitchen with limited counter or storage space.

Another advantage is its versatility. In addition to making soup, it can make plant-based milk and smoothies, and it can handle ice. It also boils water in about four to five minutes.

Hand holding up the Milkmond cotton milk straining bag in front of the white Milkmond machine
Image: Holly Phillips

The included accessories are a nice touch. The box comes with a cleaning brush and a milk bag for straining homemade plant-based milk. It also has a self-cleaning function, which makes cleanup more convenient.

What could be better

The biggest limitation is capacity. At 1 liter, it holds less than the 1.6-liter soup makers. In my experience, the two larger machines could easily make roughly twice as much soup as the Milkmond.

I also noticed some steam escapes through the holes in the top while it runs, so be mindful of where you place your hands.

Finger pressing a button on the Milkmond control panel, its display reading 21
Image: Holly Phillips

Product details

  • Capacity: 32 ounces (about 1 liter)
  • Programs: eight functions, including plant-based milk, soup and smoothies, plus boil water and keep warm
  • Blades: 10 stainless steel blades
  • Cleaning: auto-clean program; cleaning brush included
  • Extras: milk straining bag, 12-hour delay start
  • Color: white
Most versatile

The most versatile of the three, especially if you want to make homemade plant-based milk as well as soup. Its smaller size, self-cleaning function, included accessories and smooth blending make it appealing, although the 1-liter capacity may not be ideal if you regularly make soup for several people.

Pros

  • Compact design
  • Makes plant-based milk, soup and smoothies
  • Self-cleaning function
  • Cleaning brush and milk-straining bag included
  • Boiled water in about 4 to 5 minutes

Cons

  • Smaller 1-liter capacity
  • Some steam escapes through the lid
  • Still makes noticeable noise while blending

What to consider before buying a soup maker

Before choosing one of these appliances, consider a few things.

Capacity

The Homtone and Potlimepan both have a 1.6-liter capacity, while the Milkmond holds 1 liter. If you’re making soup for multiple people or want leftovers, the larger machines are probably the better choice.

Noise

None of the three machines was completely quiet. Blending started relatively quietly while the ingredients were being processed, but the machines became louder as the blending continued. The Milkmond was somewhat quieter overall.

Cleaning

Cleaning is another consideration. The Homtone has a cleaning mode, although you’ll need to check the manual to find it. The Milkmond has a self-cleaning function and comes with a brush. The Potlimepan doesn’t advertise a self-cleaning feature, but I found it easy enough to clean after use.

What you can make

All three appliances offer blending or smoothie programs, although I didn’t personally test those functions. The Milkmond stands out because it’s also designed to make plant-based milk.

One important limitation: none of these machines is designed to cook meat. If you’re looking for an appliance that can prepare a soup containing raw meat, these aren’t the machines for that job.

Building a counter full of helpers? See our 10 time-saving kitchen appliances and the best bread makers, according to baking experts.

So, which soup maker should you buy?

After testing all three, I found that each machine handled blending well and produced the smooth consistency I wanted. The biggest differences came down to capacity, cleaning features and versatility, with the Milkmond ranking highest for versatility and the two dedicated soup makers better suited to larger batches.

  • Most versatile: Milkmond (9/10). Choose the Milkmond 8-in-1 Milk Maker if you want a smaller, multipurpose appliance that can make plant-based milk, soup and other drinks.
  • Best for larger batches: Homtone (8/10). Choose the Homtone 1.6L Soup Maker if you want a larger-capacity soup maker with a cleaning mode and simple controls.
  • Best for simple controls: Potlimepan (8/10). Choose the Potlimepan 1.6L Soup Maker if you want a 1.6-liter soup maker with a digital display and multiple preset programs.

Ultimately, all three did what I needed them to do during my soup test. If capacity matters most, choose one of the two dedicated soup makers. If versatility matters most, choose the Milkmond, which is the most flexible option overall.

Who tested it

Photo of Holly Phillips

Holly Phillips

Product reviewer and writer.

Sources and further reading

Changelog

  1. Published.

What we could not test

  • These are observations from home use, not a lab test. I blended cooked ingredients on the smooth soup setting only, so I did not test cooking from raw or the chunky soup and smoothie programs.

Questions

What is the best soup maker?

It depends on what you need. The Milkmond 8-in-1 Milk Maker was the most versatile in my test, while the Homtone and Potlimepan are better for larger batches thanks to their 1.6-liter jugs.

Which soup maker is the quietest?

None of the three was completely quiet, but the Milkmond was somewhat quieter than the Homtone and Potlimepan in my test. It blends in intervals rather than continuously.

Are soup makers self-cleaning?

Some are. The Milkmond has a self-cleaning function and the Homtone has a cleaning mode, though you’ll need the manual to find it. The Potlimepan doesn’t advertise one, but it was easy to clean by hand.

Can a soup maker cook meat?

Not these three. None of them is designed to cook meat, so they’re not the right choice for a soup made with raw meat.

How much soup does a soup maker make?

The Homtone and Potlimepan hold 1.6 liters, while the Milkmond holds 1 liter. In my test, the larger machines could easily make roughly twice as much soup.