Add Consumer Echo as a preferred source on Google

How we make money. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more ›

How to Make the Perfect Cupcake: Easy Tips for the Best Bakes

Three frosted cupcakes on a white plate: one with purple frosting and a blueberry in a pink liner, one with white frosting and red heart sprinkles in a red liner, and one with sprinkles behind them
If you buy through our links we may earn a commission. It never changes what we recommend.Learn more ›
Researched

A great cupcake has a soft, even crumb, a gently rounded top, tasty colorful frosting, and a liner that peels away clean. Getting there is less about a secret recipe and more about a handful of tried-and-tested tips and habits. Here’s how to make the best cupcakes at home, batch after batch, whether you bake from scratch or from a box.

We’ve grouped our tips by stage: before you mix, mixing, filling the pan, baking, and decorating. A quick troubleshooting guide follows, and the baking supplies we reach for are at the end. Planning to bake a lot this season? See our guide to the best stand mixers too.

Overhead view of a child pouring yellow cupcake batter from a measuring cup into paper liners in a muffin pan, with eggshells on the counter
Image: Getty Images via Unsplash+

How to make the best cupcakes: start before you mix

Read the recipe all the way through

It sounds obvious, but it saves more batches than any gadget. Read every step before you start, and follow the recipe exactly the first time. Once you know how it behaves, you can play.

Set everything out first

Measure and line up every ingredient before you turn on the mixer. Bakers call this mise en place, and it means no forgotten baking powder and no scrambling while the batter sits.

Bring ingredients to room temperature

Butter, eggs, and milk blend best when none of them is cold. Room temperature ingredients come together into a smooth, even batter that traps air and bakes up light. Cold ones can leave the batter curdled and the cupcakes dense.

Weigh, don’t scoop

A kitchen scale is the easiest baking upgrade. Too much flour makes cupcakes dry and heavy, and too much sugar makes them sink or turn gummy. Weighing is more accurate than cups, and you’ll have fewer measuring tools to wash.

Mix gently for a tender crumb

Know your batter

Not every cupcake recipe behaves the same. Butter-based batters tend to bake up taller with a domed top, while oil-based batters bake a little flatter and stay moist for longer. Neither is wrong; just know which one you’re making so the results don’t surprise you.

Stop mixing sooner than you think

Overmixing causes many cupcake problems, from a tough texture to peaked or cracked tops. A hand mixer gives you more control than a stand mixer for a small batch. Mix just until the flour disappears. The batter doesn’t need to be perfectly smooth.

Fill the pan the same way every time

Pick the right liners

Greaseproof liners release the cupcake cleanly and keep their color after baking. Thin, decorative paper liners can stick, so give them a light coat of cooking spray. A quick spray across the top of the pan helps too, so any batter that spills over lifts right off.

Use a scoop for even cupcakes

Cupcakes that are all the same size bake in the same time. A spring-loaded scoop makes that easy. The number on a scoop tells you how many scoops fill a quart, so the smaller the number, the bigger the scoop; a #20 scoop holds about 3 tablespoons, a good size for standard cupcakes. For thin batters, a measuring cup with a pour spout is quicker and neater.

Fill about two-thirds full

For most scratch recipes, fill each liner about two-thirds full. Many box mixes do better closer to half full, so check the package. Smooth the tops with the back of a spoon, or tap the pan gently on the counter to settle the batter.

Bake with care

Get to know your oven

Many ovens run hotter or cooler than the dial says. An oven thermometer shows you the real temperature. Give the oven an extra 10 to 15 minutes after it says it’s ready, so the walls are hot, and the heat stays steady when you open the door.

Bake in the center and move pans gently

Bake on the middle rack for even heat. If you’re baking two pans at once, swap racks and turn the pans halfway through, and do it gently: the cupcakes haven’t set yet and can fall.

Test before you take them out

When the centers no longer look wet and shiny, give them another minute, then lightly press the top of one. If it springs back, they’re done. If it leaves a dent, give them about 2 more minutes and test again.

Cool them the right way

Let the cupcakes rest in the pan for about 5 minutes so they firm up, then move them to a wire rack. If you leave them in the pan too long, they steam and the bottoms turn soggy.

Two muffin pans of freshly baked red velvet cupcakes being pulled from an oven with oven mitts
Image: Riccardo Greg via Unsplash

Frost, decorate and store

Let them cool completely

Frosting melts and slides off warm cupcakes, so wait until they’re fully cool. In a hurry? A short fridge rest speeds things up.

Add sprinkles before you chill

A small offset spatula or icing knife spreads frosting smoothly, and a piping bag with a star tip gives you the classic swirl. Add sprinkles while the frosting is still soft. Then, if you’re moving the cupcakes, chill them for 15 to 20 minutes so the buttercream firms up and travels better.

Store them in an airtight container

Cupcakes with buttercream keep well at room temperature in an airtight container for a few days. The exceptions are cupcakes with a perishable filling or whipped cream frosting, which belong in the fridge.

Cupcake troubleshooting

Even good bakers get a strange batch now and then. Here’s what usually causes the most common problems.

  • Peaked or cracked tops: the oven is too hot, or you overmixed the batter.
  • Sinking after cooling: underbaking, overbeating, old baking powder, or too much egg. Use the egg size the recipe calls for; a large egg weighs about 50 grams out of the shell.
  • Batter overflowing: overfilled liners, too much baking powder or soda, an oven that runs cool, or a very acidic batter, such as lemon. Trim small spills with kitchen shears.
  • Cupcakes pulling away from the liner: underbaking, or stiff decorative liners that don’t move with the cake as it cools.
  • Sticky tops: sugar pulls moisture from the air. It’s harmless, just a little messy.

Our Amazon picks for baking the best cupcakes

Twelve tools that make every tip above easier: measuring and mixing in the first row, baking in the second, and decorating and carrying in the third. For more pretty kitchen tools, see our pink kitchen appliances and gear.

A stainless steel OXO digital kitchen scale with a black pull-out displayCheck price at Amazon
Image: OXO via Amazon

A scale for exact amounts

The OXO Good Grips 11-Pound Food Scale weighs in ounces, pounds, grams and kilograms. Its pull-out display stays readable under a big bowl.

A white KitchenAid hand mixer with two stainless steel beaters attachedCheck price at Amazon
Image: KitchenAid via Amazon

A hand mixer with control

The KitchenAid 5-Speed Hand Mixer runs from a slow stir to a fast whip, so it’s easy not to overmix.

Three clear Pyrex glass measuring cups with red markings in 1, 2 and 4 cup sizesCheck price at Amazon
Image: Pyrex via Amazon

Cups with a pour spout

The Pyrex Glass Measuring Cups come in 1, 2 and 4 cup sizes, handy for pouring thin batter neatly.

A stainless steel OXO scoop with black squeeze handlesCheck price at Amazon
Image: OXO via Amazon

A scoop for even sizes

The OXO Good Grips Large Cookie Scoop is a size 20 that holds 3 tablespoons, with a wiper for clean release.

A silver 12-cup USA Pan muffin pan with a ridged surfaceCheck price at Amazon
Image: USA Pan via Amazon

A classic 12-cup pan

The USA Pan 12-Well Muffin Pan is aluminized steel with a nonstick coating for easy release and cleanup.

Stacks of white pleated paper cupcake linersCheck price at Amazon
Image: Caperci via Amazon

Greaseproof liners

Caperci White Cupcake Liners are greaseproof paper in a standard size, 500 to a pack.

A round stainless steel Rubbermaid oven thermometer dial on a standCheck price at Amazon
Image: Rubbermaid via Amazon

An oven thermometer

The Rubbermaid Oven Thermometer shows your oven’s real temperature, from 60°F to 580°F.

A rectangular steel wire cooling rack with a tight gridCheck price at Amazon
Image: USA Pan via Amazon

A rack for quick cooling

The USA Pan Half Sheet Cooling Rack has a tight wire grid and six raised feet for even cooling.

Clear disposable piping bags beside a row of stainless steel piping tipsCheck price at Amazon
Image: Wilton via Amazon

A starter piping kit

The Wilton Beginning Buttercream Decorating Set includes 10 disposable icing bags and 10 stainless steel tips.

A small angled stainless steel icing knife with a black handleCheck price at Amazon
Image: OXO via Amazon

A cupcake-size spatula

The OXO Good Grips Cupcake Icing Knife has a small angled blade sized for frosting cupcakes.

A yellow and clear 10 oz bag of Wilton Rainbow Mix sprinkles with colorful jimmies and nonpareilsCheck price at Amazon
Image: Wilton via Amazon

Sprinkles for the finish

Wilton Rainbow Sprinkles Mix blends jimmies and nonpareils in a 10 oz bag.

A clear two-layer Snapware carrier with a handle, holding cupcakesCheck price at Amazon
Image: Snapware via Amazon

A carrier for 24

The Snapware 2-Layer Cupcake Carrier holds 24 cupcakes, and the layers come apart.

Sources and further reading

Changelog

  1. Written.

What we could not test

  • We haven’t tested these products.

Questions

How full should I fill cupcake liners?

About two-thirds full for most scratch recipes. Many box mixes do better closer to half full, so check the package.

How do I know when cupcakes are done?

Press the top of one lightly. If it springs back, they’re done. If it leaves a dent, bake about 2 minutes more and test again.

Why did my cupcakes sink after baking?

The usual causes are underbaking, overbeating, old baking powder or too much egg.

Do cupcakes need to be refrigerated?

Not usually. Cupcakes with buttercream keep a few days at room temperature in an airtight container. Refrigerate any with a perishable filling or whipped cream frosting.